I always shudder a little bit when these readings from Nehemiah come up because of that place-name “Water Gate.” I’m of the generation that watched a president resign–the first time that had ever happened–and the whole scandal was so associated with a building named after this famous Water Gate that we have an entire genre of “gates” now: [your scapegoat]-gate.
Curiously, or interestingly, the reading from Nehemiah points us precisely toward the sorts of crises that might lead to upsets. In the story (Nehemiah 8: 1 ff.) Nehemiah has brought the actual text of the Ten Commandments out to read them to the crowd assembled. They’re all in awe of the God who has sent them such a gift, although they haven’t heard the “rules” yet. And when Nehemiah reads the crowd breaks down and sobs uncontrollably “For all the people wept when they heard the words of the law.” We are led to believe they are sobbing in awe of their awesome God, but let’s face it, the real reason they’re sobbing probably had to do with their sudden realization that they had broken every rule in the book. If these were the rules they were … ummm, let’s use doomed here.
Or maybe they were sobbing because they knew they were going to have to give up their power and authority. And here is where I bring the story home always to the present day. We all spent a lot of energy last week being upset by the Anglican Primates and the decision at the conclusion of their meeting regarding the Episcopal Church. All week long we have been showered with official pastoral responses by almost every bishop in the Episcopal Church and many from Canada and other Anglican churches as well. But in the end it mostly all comes down to the point we find ourselves sharing with Nehemiah. Someone needs to read the two commandments, those that constitute Christianity, to those bishops from other parts of the world who seek to continue oppression of glbt people. Because my friends, there is nothing in scripture to properly account for their “conclusion” that glbt people are sinful by nature. I could rehearse all of the arguments here but I don’t need to do that, we did that decades ago. If you want, hunt back in my archives for references to the scholarly work that brings all of the proof-texts to bear. There is nothing in Christ that condemns homosexuals or homosexuality. It is a made-up position, derived from deliberate misinterpretation of Old Testament texts. In fact, there is nothing in the Old Testament that condemns homosexuals or homosexuality. There are stories about David and Jonathan and Ruth and Naomi, for example, and other examples of revelation of God’s creation of all people in God’s image, gay straight or otherwise.
So that brings us to the weepers at the Water Gate. They realized their plight, because it was not just that they had sinned and not only that they had sinned but it was really that they kept doing it on purpose. And their sin was to oppress their neighbors. Christ gave us two commandments: love God, and love each other. And Christ told us to remember that the two really were the same thing, that to love each other is to love God and to love God fully means loving each other fully. Jesus also told his disciples that whenever they went to a place to bring the Holy Spirit and they weren’t accepted they were to shake the dust off their feet and move on to another place.
So my friends, remember this: those who seek to oppress us do not need to be convinced by Scripture that they are wrong, they know they are wrong, they are doing this on purpose. They have nearly lost the fight to restrict holiness to white males, and only by continuing to oppress the weak among them can they continue to maintain power over females and non-heterosexual males. I’ve written this before (this seems to be becoming a refrain for me): the theology is not new and they’re all familiar with it. In the same way that the Roman curia knows there is no necessity to prevent the ordination of women other than as a means of control; women were among Jesus’ disciples and appear all through the New Testament as founders of the new church.
Jesus constantly reminded people that the kingdom of God had already come near, the problem was for them to put aside their self-centeredness and open their hearts to the universality of God’s creation. This is still the promise of salvation, that in Christ God has given us all that we need to be at one with God and with all of God’s creation. All we have to do is stop oppressing, stop stigmatizing, stop obsessing about self and open our hearts to the movement of a loving God whose creation encompasses all people. Even gay people.
©2016 The Rev. Dr. Richard P. Smiraglia. All rights reserved.
3 Epiphany (Nehemiah 8: 1-3, 5-6, 8-10; Psalm 19; 1 Corinthians 12: 12-31a; Luke 4:14-21)